Mari's Mailbag - Forum Debate, Not Name-Calling


Have you been to the Second Life Surfing Assocation (SLSA) forums (http://www.surfslsa.com/)? Have you noticed a particular tone in the comments? I sure have. Seems no matter what the thread is, how positive it starts out, somebody always throws in the negative comment and causes the thread to turn ugly. Is this a sport? Seems like it. I mean forums are about discussion, true.  But it should not be about slamming the guy who posted before you. This is not a sport. Sure, in debates we have disagreements, but these seem to have a real nasty tone.

Debating is a formal method of interactive and representational argument. Debate is a broader form of argument than logical argument which only examines consistency from axiom, and factual argument, which only examines what is or isn't the case, or rhetoric which is a technique of persuasion. Though logical consistency, factual accuracy and some degree of emotional appeal to the audience are important elements of the art of persuasion, in debating, one side often prevails over the other side by presenting a superior "context" and/or framework of the issue which is far more subtle and strategic. Its not name calling. Or being judgemental about someone's character. Gratuitous verbal abuse or "name-calling" itself is not a logical fallacy. The fallacy only occurs if personal attacks are employed in the stead of an argument to devalue an argument by attacking the speaker, not personal insults in the middle of an otherwise sound argument. Let's think before we speak. Let's be rational. Let's debate healthy.


Share: